Study Brief
Does the thing a cat chooses most often also work best as a reward? In one small home study, the individually top-ranked option was followed by more nose-poke responses for three of four cats. The fourth cat responded at similar levels for the top- and low-ranked options. That makes a cat's observed preference a useful clue, not a guarantee.
What did the researchers test?
Machado and colleagues studied four healthy companion cats, three female and one male, aged 10 months to 6 years. The cats were recruited by convenience from the researchers' personal and professional networks. Sessions took place in familiar rooms in the cats' homes. The paper does not identify the homes' country or region.
Researchers compared individualized food, toy, and caregiver-interaction options. During a free-choice assessment, several options were available at the same time. The researchers measured how many seconds each cat spent in the area associated with each option. This produced an individual preference ranking; it did not ask cats to rate enjoyment or predict what every cat would choose.
Preference and reinforcement were measured separately
After ranking the options, the team tested a different question: would the top-ranked option maintain a simple response more often than the lowest-ranked option? In short sessions, a caregiver presented an open hand or closed fist. A nose touch to the hand gave the cat 20 seconds of access to the assigned option. If no nose touch occurred within 40 seconds, the trial ended without access. Each session contained 10 trials, and the nose-touch response had not been formally taught beforehand.
That distinction matters. Time spent near an available option describes a choice in that moment. A reinforcer assessment asks whether access to an option follows a response and whether that response occurs again under the task. These measures are related, but they are not interchangeable.
What happened in the four-cat study?
The top-ranked category differed by cat: food ranked highest for one, caregiver interaction for two, and a toy for one. In the separate nose-touch task, three cats responded more often when the top-ranked option followed the response. One cat responded at similar rates in the two conditions.
The paper reported these descriptive averages across the four cats:
| Option provided after a nose touch | Trials with a nose-touch response | Standard error | Range across cats |
|---|---|---|---|
| Each cat's most-preferred option | 59.2% | 7.2 percentage points | 10% to 90% |
| Each cat's least-preferred option | 13.1% | 3.1 percentage points | 0% to 30% |
These percentages describe whether a response occurred on a trial, averaged across four cats. They are not the share of cats that preferred a food or toy, a training-success rate, or a population estimate. The reported ranges overlap, which is another reason not to turn the averages into a pass/fail rule for an individual cat.
Three useful ways to read the result
1. There was no single favorite category
Across four cats, the highest-ranked category was not the same. A toy, food, or caregiver interaction could rank first for an individual cat, so the study does not support a universal order such as toys before food or people before toys. Its clearest message is about individual differences within this small group.
2. A favorite was a candidate, not a promise
For three cats, the option that ranked highest during the choice assessment also maintained more responses in the later task. For the fourth, it did not produce a clear separation. A preference assessment can help identify an option worth evaluating, but it cannot by itself establish that the option will maintain a behavior in another task or at another time.
3. The average hides how much outcomes varied
Most-preferred response rates ranged from 10% to 90% across cats; least-preferred rates ranged from 0% to 30%. Those ranges overlap between 10% and 30%. This arithmetic observation is not a new statistical test, but it shows why the average difference should not be used as an individual threshold.
Study details that limit the conclusion
Four cats cannot represent the range of companion cats. The sample was small and recruited through the researchers' networks, and the study did not test whether the pattern holds across breeds, ages, homes, or other groups.
The options also differed in how cats interacted with them. Food was presented in puzzle boxes, which required more interaction than some toy and social options. The researchers noted that this difference in effort could have affected food engagement. About 2.5 hours before the first session of each day, food and toys were withheld and social opportunities were minimized as much as possible. The study did not directly measure or experimentally vary motivation. That temporary access procedure was part of the research protocol, not a home routine tested for caregivers.
The nose touch itself was not formally trained. That means the measured outcome was a cat's response to a particular hand-presentation task, not a measure of general learning ability or willingness to cooperate. It is reasonable to infer that response familiarity could matter, but the study did not isolate that factor.
The authors also left scent options out of this study. They described the preference results as a way to identify candidate reinforcers, with direct testing needed when the question is whether an option actually maintains a response.
What caregivers can take from it
In ordinary life, a cat's voluntary approach can be a clue about current interest. That is a modest observation, not a validated home assessment or a fixed label for the cat. This paper did not test a caregiver training plan, a feeding recommendation, or a method for improving welfare. It also does not show that a preferred item is always appropriate or effective in every context.
The careful takeaway is simple: preference and reward effectiveness are different questions. In this four-cat study, an individual's top-ranked option often maintained more responses, but not for every cat. The result supports paying attention to the individual while keeping the limits of one small study in view.
Sources and related reading
Primary study: Machado, M. A., Huber, H., Thompson, S., Monasky, C. A., Najafighabouri, M., and Cicchillo, B. M. (2026). Preference assessment and reinforcer effectiveness in domestic cats. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 126(3), e70148. https://doi.org/10.1002/jeab.70148.
For a separate question about feline enrichment, read what one study found when it compared food puzzles and toys for cats.







